|<<>>|32 of 260 Show listMobile Mode

Persepolis Rising by James S. A. Corey (2017) (read in 2022)

Published by marco on

Standard disclaimer[1]

This is the seventh novel in The Expanse series. It picks up the story nearly three decades after the end of the last book. The Transport Union manages traffic between the Ring Colonies, led by Camina Drummer. She is comfortable in her role, but laments the hidebound nature of bureaucracy.

“Time was supposed to heal all wounds. To Drummer, that was just a nice way of saying that if she waited long enough, none of the things that seemed important to her would turn out to matter. Or at least not the way she’d thought they did.”
Page 17
“The question wasn’t whether moving psychoactive alien seedpods between worlds was a good idea so much as whether someone was going to lose face in front of a committee meeting. Thus were the great decisions of history made.”
Page 109
“If they kill us all, Drummer thought, this will be why. Not their technology, not their strategy, not the invisible cycle of history. It’ll be our inability to do anything without five committee meetings to talk about it.”
Page 244

Avasarala shows up to offer backup, advice, and, of course, orders, even though she no longer has any official capacity.

““Don’t let things sit for too long. It’s always tempting to just ignore the things that aren’t actually on fire just at the moment, but then you’re also committing to spend your time putting out fires.””
Page 110

The Rocinante works for the Transport Union and is forced to do a prisoner transport. Holden does it, but he isn’t happy about it. This triggers a decision by Naomi and Holden to announce their retirement and hand off the Roci to Bobbie and the crew.

Naomi and Holden are on Medina Station for only a week before two Laconian ships enter the Ring System through their gate. No-one’s heard from them in almost thirty years. They’ve been busy building enormous battleships with protomolecule technology, generations ahead of what the rest of humanity is still using.

They announce that they’re there to take over the empire and for everyone to give up peacefully. Any violence will have been forced upon the Laconians, who are only interested in running the human empire better. That is, you have to do what they say all the time, but the Laconians are obviously so much better than everyone else that no-one who isn’t a complete idiot could possibly mind.

The battle of Medina Station is over quickly, with the Gathering Storm firing a magnetic cannon that destroys the rail guns on the old station and also rings it like a bell, emitting a tremendous amount of energy. That means that they can use it anytime to control the gates—all with one ship. The other, even larger, ship Heart of the Tempest, captained by Admiral Trejo, heads into the Sol System ahead of schedule. Its mission is get Earth’s capitulation.

They occupy Media Station and install Governor Singh to oversee the occupation. Although he was nominated by Commandante Duarte as one of the best and the brightest that the Laconian academies had to offer, he is both spectacularly bereft of practical experience and also remarkably thin-skinned. However, it’s not yet clear how the rest of humanity is going to react. Predictably, it reacts all of the ways at once.

“There were thousands of feeds streaming right now, all around the system, with every variation of the ways to make sense of the history they were living through. In most, Laconia was an invading force to be resisted, but there were people who said Laconia was a liberating influence, an end to the oppression of the EMC and the Transport Union. Or that they were the true spirit of Mars, betrayed by the old congressional republic and now returned in triumph. Or that they were unbeatable, and capitulation was the only choice.”
Page 243

The crew of the Roci reunites with Naomi and Holden, going into hiding with Drummer’s husband Saba’s crew. They are the underground, revolting against Laconian rule.

““This here?” Amos said. He pointed at the Marine outside, the security drones that now hovered over every part of Medina’s drum, the people in Laconian Navy uniforms everywhere. “I’ve seen this before. This is us getting paved over. All we can do now is try to find some cracks to grow through.””
Page 164

Clarissa chimes in on the nature of powerful, rich men (having grown up around her father, Jules-Pierre Mao),

“[…] some men just need to own everything. Anything they lay their eyes on that they don’t possess, it’s like a sliver in their finger.””
Page 166
““My father could be the kindest, most generous and loving man. Right up until he wanted something and you wouldn’t give it to him. I don’t know why I think this, but Duarte feels the same. And these are men who will mercilessly punish anyone who won’t comply, but with tears in their eyes and begging you to tell them why you made them do it.””
Page 166

Naomi adds her view, as a Belter:

““You’re new here,” she said. “I’m a Belter. Security coming down on you just because they can? Checkpoints and identity tracking? Knowing that you could wind up in the recycler for any reason or no reason? I grew up like this. Amos did too, in his way. I never wanted to come back here, but I know how this all goes. Childhood memories, sa sa que?””
Page 183

Whereas Amos rounds things out with a very Amos-like summary:

““All right, then,” Bobbie said. “The way I see it, the next step is find someone who can get messages back to the union. Or Earth-Mars. See if there’s anyone out there with a plan, or if we’re going to have to make one up on our own.”

““We can do that,” Amos said. “Shouldn’t be hard.”

““You sure?” Alex said. “This is Medina Station under occupation by a bunch of splinter Martian military expats. It’s not Baltimore.”

“Amos’ smile was as placid as always. “Everywhere’s Baltimore.””

Page 194

Their first real act of sabotage is to set a bomb, built with the help of the age-old Belter gang Voltaire Collective. The bomb is not meant to achieve any goal, but to distract the Laconians while Bobbie and Clarissa hook into the Laconians encrypted data feed.

The next underground attack is to get the encryption codes. For this, they set another bomb to make it look like they were attacking the Gathering Storm, but they were really attacking the data-encryption station. During this attack, though, Holden is taken prisoner. They have the information, though, and they discover that another gigantic ship is on its way, the Eye of the Typhoon.

Singh is not handling this well at all. He is excited to have captured Holden because now he can convince the leader of the rebellion of how amazing, benevolent, and inevitable the Laconian Empire is.

He’s a slow learner, though. Speaking to the president of the colonies, he says,

““It’s come to my attention that many of the social organizations of the old human power structures show a shocking inability to do risk analysis. They may foolishly attempt a doomed assault, thinking all they’re risking is their own lives. Reason doesn’t work with this kind of person. I need you to make them understand, on an emotional level, the price for such an attack. I will kill every single person on their planet. I assume even former OPA radicals have family members they care about, and whose lives they are less willing to risk on a romantic notion of a hero’s death.””
Page 257

He’s still not getting it. He’s also not getting that there is no benevolence anymore. That any such benevolence was only in exchange for absolute and immediate fealty. People can’t tell the difference between good intentions forced into authoritarianism and outright, venal authoritarianism. Because there is none, for them.

Singh reminds me of Soltan Gris, from L. Ron Hubbard’s Mission Earth series. His conversations with Holden are very reminiscent of those between Gris and Jettero Heller.[2]

“Holden sipped his coffee. “That’s the thing. The people you’re controlling don’t have a voice in how you control them. As long as everyone’s on the same page, things may be great, but when there’s a question, you win. Right?””
Page 384
““Not that academic,” Holden said. “I’ve spent a lot of years trying to get people to get along without anyone’s boot being on anyone’s neck. Your plan A is what I’ve spent a lifetime pushing against.””
Page 384

““The high consul is a very wise, very thoughtful man,” he said. “I have perfect faith that—”

““No. Stop. ‘Perfect faith’ really tells me everything I need to know,” Holden said. “You think this is a gentle, bloodless conquest, don’t you?”

““It is, to the degree that you allow it to be.”

““I was there for the war Duarte started to cover his tracks. I was there for the starving years afterward. Your empire’s hands look a lot cleaner when you get to dictate where history begins and what parts of it don’t count.””

Page 385

Meanwhile, all of Sol System’s massed forces have proven to be no match for a single Laconian ship. It shrugs off all attacks, destroys everything in its path, and forces a surrender. Drummer tenders the surrender, with Avasarala looking on. Drummer thinks the following, but does not act on it. Instead, she chooses to save millions of lives. The sentiment will, however, come back to haunt Laconia, one can be relatively certain.

“[…] we have been conquered, but we will fight to the last breath because living with someone else’s hand on our necks is intolerable, has always been intolerable, will always be intolerable. Not because of Laconia, not because of the union, not because of any of the authorities through all of history that have made rules and then dared people to break them. Because we’re human, and humans are mean, independent monkeys that reached their greatness by killing every other species of hominid that looked at us funny. We will not be controlled for long. Not even by ourselves. Any other plan is a pipe dream.”
Page 519

Their weapons were just too powerful. The Union’s top scientist describes the situation,

““Ma’am, that ship stripped Pallas Station down to something less than atoms. It shut down consciousness throughout the system in a way that I don’t have the structural language to explain, and it seems pretty fucking unimpressed by the idea of locality. It’s affecting the nature of vacuum through the whole solar system. If you didn’t know we were punching above our weight here, I’m not sure what I could have said to clarify that.””
Page 451

Singh reveals to Holden that the Tempest had an unexplained phenomenon on board: one of the bizarre “bullets” appeared out of nowhere. Holden had found one of these on Ilus and learned that it is an artifact of the civilization that destroyed the protomolecule civilization. It appeared out of nowhere when the Tempest fired its magnetic weapon in Sol System. They have been detected.

Singh, in his typical miscomprehension, figures it would be best to send Holden back to Duarte on Laconia. Naomi is heartbroken when she discovers this, but she continues with their plan to help the underground escape from Medina. The plan is complex: Saba frees prisoners, they use a secret lockdown code to freeze all of the powered Laconian armor, Clarissa and Naomi disable the sensor array, Alex steals the Rocinante and takes off, and Bobbie and Amos board the Gathering Storm.

A Belter named Jordao betrays Clarissa and Naomi. They manage to shunt off the sensor array, but Jordao is about to tell the Laconians where it is. Instead, Clarissa—who’s been ill from her implants for a long time—uses them one last time to destroy all opposition and save the mission.

The Storm has only a skeleton crew, which makes it easier for Bobbie and Amos to take it over. It’s not easy—they can barely cut through the hull because of the advanced, self-healing materials—but they manage it. Instead of scuttling it, they’ve managed to steal it. With the Storm out of the way, the other twenty ships leave Medina Station and, inside of 90 minutes, all of them are through one gate or another.

Singh loses all control, ordering his head of security Overstreet to eliminate most of the other people on the station as reprisal. Instead, Overstreet says that he has higher orders: uphold the Laconian code. He executes Singh. They retain control over Medina station, but the underground has escaped to fight another day.

Holden is in a prison on Laconia, a special guest of Duarte. Amos and Bobbie are in orbit above Freehold, where Alex and Naomi have landed the Roci. Naomi considers her situation,

“She’d seen a map once—the splash of systems that the gates connected. Thirteen hundred stars in a galaxy with three hundred billion of them. They’d been clumped together, the gate-network stars. The two farthest systems were hardly more than a thousand light-years apart. A little more than one percent of the galaxy, and still unthinkably vast.”
Page 526
“Everything changed, and it went right on changing. A terrible thought when things were good, a comforting one now. Whatever happened, she could be certain that things wouldn’t stay the way they were now. And if she stayed smart and clever and lucky, she’d be able to affect how the next change came. Or take advantage of it.”
Page 528


[1] Disclaimer: these are notes I took while reading this book. They include citations I found interesting or enlightening or particularly well-written. In some cases, I’ve pointed out which of these applies to which citation; in others, I have not. Any benefit you gain from reading these notes is purely incidental to the purpose they serve of reminding me of what I once read. Please see Wikipedia for a summary if I’ve failed to provide one sufficient for your purposes. If my notes serve to trigger an interest in this book, then I’m happy for you.
[2] It’s been about 35 years since I read them, so there may be a good amount of confabulation here.

Citations

“Time was supposed to heal all wounds. To Drummer, that was just a nice way of saying that if she waited long enough, none of the things that seemed important to her would turn out to matter. Or at least not the way she’d thought they did.”
Page 17
“There are always people who are wary of change. And that’s a good thing. Change should be watched, moderated, and questioned. But that conservative view shouldn’t rein in progress or put a damper on hope.”
Page 22
“Every great nation, they said, was founded on a knife and a lie.”
Page 58
““They didn’t vote for Drummer,” he said, tapping hard on the screen. “They can’t appeal her decisions, and she has the power of life and death over them. She needs to be held to a higher standard than ‘whatever’s most convenient.’ And in every military service in history, when the commander gave an immoral command, it was the duty of the soldiers to disobey it.””
Page 67
“Any of it could be the key to unimagined miracles. Or catastrophe. Or placebo-euphoric snake-oil light-show bullshit. The images from the seedpods could be the encrypted records of the fallen civilization that had built miracles they were still only beginning to understand. Or they could be the spores of whatever had killed them. Or they could be lava lamps. Who fucking knew?”
Page 109
“The question wasn’t whether moving psychoactive alien seedpods between worlds was a good idea so much as whether someone was going to lose face in front of a committee meeting. Thus were the great decisions of history made.”
Page 109
““Don’t let things sit for too long. It’s always tempting to just ignore the things that aren’t actually on fire just at the moment, but then you’re also committing to spend your time putting out fires.””
Page 110
“Only it was her battle now, and while she was very clear that she was in the right, it was also evident that her position wasn’t going to help her change Langstiver’s plan. She couldn’t beat sense into a stone. Not even when it seemed fun to try.”
Page 121

““I’m telling you he came back because he thinks he can win,” Avasarala said. “And if he thinks that, you should prepare yourself for the idea that it’s true.”

““There’s no point, then,” Drummer said. “We should just roll over? Put our necks under his boot and hope he doesn’t step on us too hard?”

““Of course not. But don’t talk yourself into underestimating him because you want him to be the next Marco Inaros. Duarte won’t hand you a win by being a dumbfuck. He won’t spread himself too thin. He won’t overreach. He won’t make up half a dozen plans and then spin a bottle to pick one. He’s a chess player. And if you act on instinct, do the thing your feelings demand, he’ll beat us all.””

Page 145
“The absurdities and accidents of human character that affected the flow of goods and information in ways that were as unpredictable as they were exhausting. Like having to throw an entire branch of Medina’s infrastructure staff in the brig.”
Page 151

Yes, the natives can be so exhausting.

““This here?” Amos said. He pointed at the Marine outside, the security drones that now hovered over every part of Medina’s drum, the people in Laconian Navy uniforms everywhere. “I’ve seen this before. This is us getting paved over. All we can do now is try to find some cracks to grow through.””
Page 164
“And some men just need to own everything. Anything they lay their eyes on that they don’t possess, it’s like a sliver in their finger.””
Page 166
““My father could be the kindest, most generous and loving man. Right up until he wanted something and you wouldn’t give it to him. I don’t know why I think this, but Duarte feels the same. And these are men who will mercilessly punish anyone who won’t comply, but with tears in their eyes and begging you to tell them why you made them do it.””
Page 166
““You’re new here,” she said. “I’m a Belter. Security coming down on you just because they can? Checkpoints and identity tracking? Knowing that you could wind up in the recycler for any reason or no reason? I grew up like this. Amos did too, in his way. I never wanted to come back here, but I know how this all goes. Childhood memories, sa sa que?””
Page 183

““All right, then,” Bobbie said. “The way I see it, the next step is find someone who can get messages back to the union. Or Earth-Mars. See if there’s anyone out there with a plan, or if we’re going to have to make one up on our own.”

““We can do that,” Amos said. “Shouldn’t be hard.”

““You sure?” Alex said. “This is Medina Station under occupation by a bunch of splinter Martian military expats. It’s not Baltimore.”

“Amos’ smile was as placid as always. “Everywhere’s Baltimore.””

Page 194
“History was a cycle. Everything that had happened before, all the way back through the generations, would happen again. Sometimes the wheel turned quickly, sometimes it was slow. She could see it like a feed gear, all teeth and bearings with her on the rim along with everybody else. Her last thought before forgetfulness took her and she fell deeply into slumber was that even with the gates, nothing really ever changed so much as repeated itself, over and over, with all new people, forever.”
Page 207
“The destroyer—Holden had called it the Gathering Storm—looked like a natural crystal formation that someone had chipped into a knife. The colors were all translucent pinks and blues, faceted like a gem.”
Page 238
“She wasn’t ready. Rock hoppers full of gravel were burning hard for positions that didn’t matter anymore. The EMC fleet was consolidating around the inner planets and the Jovian system, but with days—sometimes weeks—left on their burns. The void cities were looping down to meet them. All of it preparation for tactical situations that weren’t on the board anymore.”
Page 239
“We recognize the deep cultural and historical importance of Sol system, and hope that this transition can be made peacefully and with the minimum of disruption. In the event that local forces resist, I am prepared and authorized to take any actions necessary to complete my mission. High Consul Duarte and I extend our best wishes to the local residents, and ask that you contact your governments to urge them to act in the name of peace. Violence is always a loss, and the measure of that loss is entirely in your control. The false gentility of the threat made her wish he’d just said he’d burn their cities and take their children. It would have felt more honest.”
Page 242
“There were thousands of feeds streaming right now, all around the system, with every variation of the ways to make sense of the history they were living through. In most, Laconia was an invading force to be resisted, but there were people who said Laconia was a liberating influence, an end to the oppression of the EMC and the Transport Union. Or that they were the true spirit of Mars, betrayed by the old congressional republic and now returned in triumph. Or that they were unbeatable, and capitulation was the only choice.”
Page 243
“If they kill us all, Drummer thought, this will be why. Not their technology, not their strategy, not the invisible cycle of history. It’ll be our inability to do anything without five committee meetings to talk about it.”
Page 244
““Our mandate from High Consul Duarte is to win over the population of this station, as a first step in winning over the population of the colony worlds. We do that by entangling our interests. By teaching them that what they think of as ‘informing’ is actually just good citizenship. This is just a first step in building what will hopefully be a network of cooperators to help us.””
Page 254

Omg hahahaha.

“He wondered what their first meeting would have been like if he’d come to her office instead of bringing her to his. Seeing all of this, he might have recommended against working with her at all.”
Page 256

Sometimes I think they’re overdoing the overconfidence and stupidity, but then I remember the template. It’s realistic.

““It’s come to my attention that many of the social organizations of the old human power structures show a shocking inability to do risk analysis. They may foolishly attempt a doomed assault, thinking all they’re risking is their own lives. Reason doesn’t work with this kind of person. I need you to make them understand, on an emotional level, the price for such an attack. I will kill every single person on their planet. I assume even former OPA radicals have family members they care about, and whose lives they are less willing to risk on a romantic notion of a hero’s death.””
Page 257

Still not getting it. Also not getting that there is no benevolence anymore. That was only in exchange for absolute and immediate fealty. People can’t tell the difference between good intentions forced into authoritarianism and outright, venal authoritarianism. Because there is none, for them.

““From the Bible. Revelation. When the devil fell from grace, he took a third of the angels with him. It’s described as the great dragon pulling a third of the stars of heaven down with its tail.””
Page 268

“Holden was smiling like a salesman, as if his radiant goodwill could warm up every other interaction in the room. It left him looking more than a little ridiculous, but damned if Katria didn’t consider him for a long moment and chuckle. “If I refuse, then we all took a long walk for nothing,” she said.

“Holden beamed. Bobbie wasn’t sure how he did it. The way he could disarm a situation with his almost palpable guilelessness astonished her every time. “Thank you,” Holden said. “I really appreciate this.””

Page 296
““And what,” Singh said after he’d let her squirm enough, “would be a better use of your time, Madam President?””
Page 310

Now I remember who Singh reminds me of: Soltan Gris, L. Ron Hubbard’s Mission Earth series.

““You don’t trust your people’s discipline?” Bobbie asked.

“Saba pointed at the closed door. “My people are the crew on the Malaclypse. These others weren’t mine until they stopped being Drummer’s. And she’s had five or six layers of bureaucrats between. It’s not I don’t trust, it’s that I don’t trust blind. People are people. Fucked up like we all are, it amazes me when we can even make a sandwich.””

Page 379
“Holden sipped his coffee. “That’s the thing. The people you’re controlling don’t have a voice in how you control them. As long as everyone’s on the same page, things may be great, but when there’s a question, you win. Right?””
Page 384
““Not that academic,” Holden said. “I’ve spent a lot of years trying to get people to get along without anyone’s boot being on anyone’s neck. Your plan A is what I’ve spent a lifetime pushing against.””
Page 384

““The high consul is a very wise, very thoughtful man,” he said. “I have perfect faith that—”

““No. Stop. ‘Perfect faith’ really tells me everything I need to know,” Holden said. “You think this is a gentle, bloodless conquest, don’t you?”

““It is, to the degree that you allow it to be.”

““I was there for the war Duarte started to cover his tracks. I was there for the starving years afterward. Your empire’s hands look a lot cleaner when you get to dictate where history begins and what parts of it don’t count.””

Page 385
““Look,” Holden said. “You and me? We’re not friends. We aren’t going to be friends. I will oppose you and your empire to my dying breath. But right now, none of that matters. Whatever built the gates and the protomolecule and all these ruins we’re living in? They were wiped out. And the thing that wiped them out just took a shot at you.””
Page 388
“Saba’s eyes softened. “My lady wife is back in Sol leading the fight against these bastards. And I will move worlds to wake up beside her again. Just once more.””
Page 401
“[…] woman with a heart-shaped face peered past the guard’s shoulder, straining to catch a glimpse of him, and Singh waved at her. Let the civilians see that their governor was here, not hiding away in his office. If he wasn’t scared of the terrorists, the loyal faction of the population wouldn’t be either. Or less so, anyway.”
Page 415

That’s lovely, again. Singh is absolutely demented.

“[…] the old woman sighed, “[…] It’d be a better world if there was always at least one right answer instead of a basket of fucked.””
Page 423

““We have expended two-thirds of our rail-gun ammunition,” the weapons tech announced. “Shall I maintain fire?”

““Yes,” Drummer said. “Then start putting chairs in the launcher. We hit that thing until we’re down to pillows and beer.”

““Understood, ma’am,” the weapons tech said. She could hear the smile in his voice. She felt it too—the giddy sense that even if they were winning ugly, they were at least winning.”

Page 427
““Ma’am, that ship stripped Pallas Station down to something less than atoms. It shut down consciousness throughout the system in a way that I don’t have the structural language to explain, and it seems pretty fucking unimpressed by the idea of locality. It’s affecting the nature of vacuum through the whole solar system. If you didn’t know we were punching above our weight here, I’m not sure what I could have said to clarify that.””
Page 451
““It wouldn’t be the first time something like that had happened. The one thing you know about someone who’s willing to compromise his allies is that he’s willing to compromise his allies.””
Page 461

““You got a plan?” Amos asked.

““That’d be generous,” she said, “but I’ve got something I’m going to do.””

Page 491

“It’s like I missed a day at school, and everyone else learned to speak Mandarin while I was gone. I don’t understand any of this.”

““Yeah,” Drummer said. “I can see that.”

““It’s the reward of old age,” Avasarala said. “You live long enough, and you can watch everything you worked for become irrelevant.”

““You’re not selling it,” Drummer said.

““Fuck you, then. Die young. See if I care.” Drummer laughed. Avasarala grinned, and for a moment, they understood each other perfectly. For a moment, Drummer didn’t feel alone.”

Page 517
“[…] we have been conquered, but we will fight to the last breath because living with someone else’s hand on our necks is intolerable, has always been intolerable, will always be intolerable. Not because of Laconia, not because of the union, not because of any of the authorities through all of history that have made rules and then dared people to break them. Because we’re human, and humans are mean, independent monkeys that reached their greatness by killing every other species of hominid that looked at us funny. We will not be controlled for long. Not even by ourselves. Any other plan is a pipe dream.”
Page 519
“Naomi looked up at the little slice of stars. The galactic disk looked the same as it had in Sol system, but the constellations not quite like her own. Parallax, she knew, was how they’d started mapping which systems were on the other sides of the gates. She’d seen a map once—the splash of systems that the gates connected. Thirteen hundred stars in a galaxy with three hundred billion of them. They’d been clumped together, the gate-network stars. The two farthest systems were hardly more than a thousand light-years apart. A little more than one percent of the galaxy, and still unthinkably vast.”
Page 526
“[…] the sense of being in midnight under stars in the middle of an ocean of air that wouldn’t run out or leak away. It really was reassuring in a way that even the best station atmosphere could never quite equal.”
Page 527
“Everything changed, and it went right on changing. A terrible thought when things were good, a comforting one now. Whatever happened, she could be certain that things wouldn’t stay the way they were now. And if she stayed smart and clever and lucky, she’d be able to affect how the next change came. Or take advantage of it.”
Page 528
“Duarte had known people like him from his time in the service. Hotheads and gadflies. The ones who were always sure they knew better than anyone else. The truth was, they had their place. Like anyone else, they could be apt tools if they were well suited to the task at hand.”
Page 533

Hey, neat! Now we know where Singh learned how to underestimate people.

““Interesting problem? Something fired a shot at you. At your ship. It turned off people’s minds all throughout the system, and that’s an interesting problem? That was an attack.”

““And it didn’t work,” Duarte said. “We aren’t the same thing that got wiped out before. What killed them affected us, but it didn’t destroy us.””

Page 535
““There was no path where we left the gates alone. No future where we didn’t use the technologies and lessons we learned from them. And there wasn’t likely to be one where we didn’t face the same kind of pushback that killed the ones who came before us. There was only the way forward where we were scattershot and chaotic, or the one where we were organized, regimented, and disciplined.”
Page 536

Which way is better? Chaotic? Or organic? And what’s the hurry? Humanity needs to grow up first. Thirty years is nothing.